• About
  • Articles
  • Book Club
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
  • Contributors
  • Toolkit
No Result
View All Result
Proud Places
  • About
  • Articles
  • Book Club
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
  • Contributors
  • Toolkit
No Result
View All Result
Proud Places
No Result
View All Result

They always said: If You’re Not Growing, You’re Dying 

By John Giusto

October 14, 2020

“All Growth is Good Growth!”

This is a common belief in America, and it inspired a great discussion on a recent Pod Places podcast. 

The first part of the conversation revolved around the nature of growth, and another lamented the loss of accessible countryside to development sprawl, and what we can do about it.

As part of this post, we’re debuting the first of a series of photo essays exploring America’s growth and investment efforts of the past. We’ll survey the Library of Congress archive of John Margolis’ images taken of places in the US around 40 years ago. In today’s piece, we’re exploring New York State. As a center of finance and culture emanating from Wall St and Madison Avenue, you’d think the rest of the state would have world-class investments, too. But outside of the NYC metropolitan area, it’s still depopulating, with only relatively few successful long-term investments.

 

The Pros Of Growth

While some may bristle at the statement that all growth is good growth in terms of development, it’s understandable that many feel this way. Some places need to grow. 

For example, many places are in the middle of nowhere, trying to build a sustainable community and desperately in need of local jobs and investment. Others still have gone through a rough time of economic and social decline. 

Development is intended to bring new economic activity and new people into places that need this kind of infusion, but the kind of activity does matter.

The Limits Of Growth

Growth for its own sake has a terrible track record. You don’t want to go through the expense of growing, and end up having nothing really good to show for it. Worse still is ending up with less than you had before, but now with legacy maintenance liabilities as far as the eye can see. 

This concern about growth isn’t just about communities and towns— it’s a problem with businesses, too. During our current economic and health crisis, many big companies have gone under because they focused on growth over stability and didn’t have enough margin for resilience. 

For much of upstate New York, the selling of bucolic views from a remote Inn like this has been a common form of economic development.

The Quick Shot-in-the-Arm Agenda

It’s sadly common for places to end up selling themselves out for a couple bucks per parcel. Places that have sold for the short-term like this underestimate what they could have become.

Some American towns are fortunate enough to still have an intact historic main street, maybe with a few square miles of underutilized land around it, where it would be so easy to build more of what they had that worked so well in the past. 

But by the end of the 20th century, building that way became illegal, thanks to zoning, land use, and transportation ordinances. So instead, the only option became to grow and sprawl out like dime-a-dozen, Anywhere-Burbs or No-Place-in-Particular-Towns. 

This place was Infamous, and now mercifully gone.

Everyone’s seen these places before– they’re everywhere these days. But somehow, no one is clamoring to move in– and those who already do live there are still leaving (or trying to leave), despite the “investment.” Understandably, most young people in particular, want more sociable, convenient, and sustainable lifestyles than these places can currently provide. 

These highly-engineered (yet cheap) places don’t build pride. In fact, they’ve been proven to be incapable of it, as evidenced by the spreading scourge of municipal failures and social discord across the country.

These stucco swordsmen flank the entrance of a Long Island restaurant on the way to the Hamptons. After traveling to Spain and Italy in the late 19th century, an American artist realized his personal vision of Casa Basso, which is now a $40 per dish roadside stop.

Making Room for Other Choices

To be clear, no one at Proud Places is trying to ban new-build roadside subdivisions. We just recognize that there are other forms of development, that are, in fact, now illegal, and we want to correct that. Everyone deserves more options than what’s currently allowed in the United States. People should have many choices available to them. This is America, after all. 

No clue what happened to this place, but if gone, a sad loss of a bespoke slate roof.

We’re just giving voice and vision for those people who want something different, and in particular, more compact and walkable. 

We speak for those who long for the convenience and simple pleasures of small quiet streets with everything you need for daily life within a 10-minute walk, for those who want homes that are close enough to foster convivial neighborliness, and for those who believe that these things are worth fighting for. 

 

A real moonshot of a restaurant, sadly now lost to time.

Unfortunately, there are so few examples of these types of compact, pedestrian-focused places in the country, and the very few that do exist have become expensive enclaves for the elite. 

And yet, when people actually experience a well-proportioned, human-scaled place, it can be an epiphany. They realize, “Wow, this is what it could be like. It’s just so simple and convenient. Why can’t I live in a place like this, too?” 

 

An old-school tourist trap that has since consolidated in one of the remaining industrial buildings.

Lamenting the Loss of Countryside Local Swimming Holes and Country Roads 

Another interesting part of the podcast was a discussion lamenting the fact that most Americans don’t live in a place with local countryside anymore.

Sprawl has consumed everything, and it might take an hours-long drive just to get to something as simple as a swimming hole or a quiet country road to learn how to ride a bike on. These are things people used to take for granted as local walk/bike-to features even just a generation ago. But now, it’s common for people to have lived their whole lives never seeing a fishing hole or a hillside meadow to have a picnic on. 

 

Once the center of a hamlet, lost to fire.

It’s something you see when watching one of those European cross-country bicycle races on TV. 

They’re rolling past the fields in the middle of the countryside, and then—all of a sudden—they’re in the middle of a community, riding past townhouse apartments and umbrella’d cafe tables on the public squares. And then just a second later they’re back in the countryside. 

As an example, here’s a hyperlapse showing a countryside ride between two Dutch town centers:

Growth Without Sprawl

Now, heading into the middle of the 21st century, there’s an opportunity to create more compact types of places again, where we can add, let’s say, 10,000 people to a community and make amazing public amenities, while preserving our countryside and natural amenities. 

We’re fighting for it to be more compact, because we want to protect the rivers, mountains and farms. We not only want—but need—these sorts of familiar environments in our lives again.

What do you know about this building or any other of the lost places? Leave a comment below.

This can be done by returning to the practice of building 2-8 story attached buildings that face small, pedestrianized streets. Just look at what’s worked for thousands of years around the world before the 20th-century experiment of automobile-enabling sprawl.

Arguably the most well-known place in NY State. A virtual village just off an old commuter train line.

Many places are growing by those 10,000 people (or much more) anyway. So either we start providing options for compact development, or we’re going to have to put those 10,000+ people into new sprawl, with all its accompanying traffic, tensions and associated costs. 

There are tens of millions of Americans who are desperately yearning for more durable community forms, where kids and the aged participate in—and are central to—the neighborly normalcy of walkable streets. 

And finally, maybe the most successful place on our list. No doubt due to proximity–it’s across the street from a high-school, and near a Long Island Sound beach and the New Haven commuter train line. Walter’s has grown into a veritable institution.
Share125Tweet78

John Giusto

John Giusto is co-founder of B4place, a Netherlands-based consulting firm focusing on countryside-conserving design visualizations and narratives.

Related Posts

Planning Ahead for 2021: Six Super Affordable Things You Can Do To Make Your Community Stronger
Civic Pride

Planning Ahead for 2021: Six Super Affordable Things You Can Do To Make Your Community Stronger

January 19, 2021

When we think about annual goals, we often think about our personal goals - weights, eating healthy, drinking more water, etc. but…. what about your community goals?  Well, we have you covered! Here are six extremely low cost and...

Internal Benefits of Community Branding
Civic Pride

A Crisis of Class (The Curse of Soft Pants)

November 16, 2020

 I love looking at historic photos and seeing how our places have changed over time. Something that always stands out, is how nice everyone dressed in the past.  No matter what job they had, or what activity they were...

We Need More Emilees, Pink Buildings, and Ice Cream.
General

We Need More Emilees, Pink Buildings, and Ice Cream.

October 18, 2020

We need more Emilees. More pink buildings. And more ice cream.  The story of Two Rivers, WI is pretty special, but it’s also similar in many ways to communities around the country.  Two Rivers is a beautiful place located...

Cities for People: Four Big Ideas from Copenhagen
Placemaking

Cities for People: Four Big Ideas from Copenhagen

October 15, 2020

A year ago, I was bouncing on a sidewalk trampoline in Copenhagen. The trampoline had no safety sign or railings, it was just a random trampoline in the middle of the sidewalk. In fact, it looks like a sewer...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

  • Civic Pride (4)
  • Communication (1)
  • Community Development (14)
  • Diversity (1)
  • Economic Development (10)
  • General (25)
  • Ideas (5)
  • Marketing (7)
  • Placemaking (10)
  • Podcast (1)
  • Real Estate Development (5)
  • Small Business (4)
  • Story Time (2)
  • Urban Planning (1)
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Articles
  • Book Club
  • Podcasts
  • Shop
  • Contributors
  • Toolkit